Would You Send Your Child to an Elite Boarding School Like Phillips Exeter?
When the thought of sending our child to an elite boarding school like Phillips Exeter first crossed my mind, I hesitated. While the idea of giving my child the best education and opportunities available is appealing, the practical and philosophical implications are complex.
The Pros and Cons of Elite Boarding Schools
The main advantage often touted for attending such an institution has little to do with the quality of education itself. Instead, it lies in the network and connections cultivated through these schools. Alumni networks often favor other alumni when seeking employees or awarding contracts, providing students with an early and possibly unfair advantage in the professional world. Additionally, students from posh schools often exude a level of confidence that can sometimes overshadow their actual abilities.
Furthermore, the homogenous environment of elite boarding schools can create an echo chamber effect, reinforcing certain ideologies and lifestyles without exposing students to a wide array of perspectives and ways of living. This can lead to a narrow-minded approach to life and an inherent bias in choosing career paths and lifestyle.
Alternative Approaches to Education
Reflecting on my own ideology and responsibilities as a parent, I envisioned a different path. I wanted my children to be nurtured and taught a wide range of subjects and life lessons. I valued the importance of diversity in their social circle, not just their peer group, to foster a broader understanding and appreciation of different cultures and lifestyles. My aim was for them to develop the ability to question and research, to navigate the challenges and opportunities that life presents, and to make informed decisions that positively impact not only themselves but others as well.
As an alternative to traditional schooling, my children also experienced home education. This approach allowed me to tailor their learning experiences to their individual needs and preferences, incorporating visits to places that could further enhance their education and understanding of the world.
Personal Reflections and Future Plans
While I cannot predict with certainty which path my children will choose, I have certain expectations based on my experience and observations at Phillips Exeter Academy (PEA).
My son, despite being very bright, requires close supervision. The independent and structured environment of an elite boarding school might not be the ideal setting for him. His current need for more guidance suggests that a nurturing and supportive environment is more appropriate for his development. However, his future is not set, and as he grows, so may his adaptability and personality.
However, after observing the environment at PEA, I do not foresee my son thriving in such a setting. His emotional and educational needs align more closely with a nurturing and flexible approach, such as that provided by home education and diverse experiences in the real world.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to send a child to an elite boarding school like Phillips Exeter Academy should be carefully considered. While it offers unique advantages, such as networking and confidence, it may not be the best fit for every child. A personalized and diverse educational experience, like home education, can provide a well-rounded and enriching environment that nurtures a child's natural talents and future success.