Why the Goldcloaks in ASOIAF Appear so Useless: Examining Their Inspiration
Have you ever wondered why the Goldcloaks in A Song of Ice and Fire (ASOIAF) seem so ineffective? Originally inspired by the Praetorian Guard of Ancient Rome, they were a symbol of the elite, protecting the empire. However, in practice, they are often depicted as corrupt, ineffectual, and even cowardly. In this article, we explore the reasons behind this portrayal, drawing parallels to the historical Praetorian Guard.
Introduction to the Goldcloaks
In the world of ASOIAF, the Goldcloaks are the royal guards of King’s Landing. They are meant to police the city, ensuring a sense of security and stability. However, their actions often belie their intended purpose. Despite being a renowned and supposedly loyal force, they are frequently depicted as extorting local businesses, indulging in drinking at brothels, and engaging in rioting and flight during critical times.
Comparing the Goldcloaks to the Praetorian Guard
The Praetorians of Ancient Rome were similarly impressive in their grand design but fall short of their promise in reality. On paper, these guardsmen were the elite force of the emperor, yet they were often more trouble than they were worth. They were extremely overpaid and underused, and their loyalty was frequently bought or lost to corruption.
The most telling example of their ineffectiveness is a humorous anecdote where a group of Praetorians is tasked with marching north but soon tire after only 15 miles. Instead of managing a camp, they decide to rest, only to be attacked and defeated by a rival legion. This incident perfectly encapsulates the inefficacy and overindulgence of the Praetorian Guard.
Successions and Corruption in the Goldcloaks
The Goldcloaks of ASOIAF have faced similar issues, often becoming corrupt due to overindulgence and the right price. Commanders like Janos Slynt have risen through the ranks by bribing, blackmailing, and bullying. Slynt, in particular, demonstrates how far corruption can go. He is known for his brutality, even suggesting the killing of a baby when necessary. Such actions underscore his cowardly nature and the corruption that permeates the Goldcloak ranks.
It is worth noting that not all Goldcloaks are this way. Some, like Ironhand, are principled and effective, earning the trust of Lord Tyrion Lannister. However, during the Battle of Blackwater Bay, a significant number of Goldcloaks either die in battle or abandon their posts, indicating a lack of overall effectiveness.
Conclusion: The True Nature of the Goldcloaks
The story of the Goldcloaks in ASOIAF reflects the general downfall and corruption that can arise from misplaced trust and indulgence. Just as the Praetorian Guard became a reviled institution, the Goldcloaks of King’s Landing are a cautionary tale of a once-honorable force that has been co-opted by corruption and greed. By understanding the historical context of the Praetorian Guard, we can better appreciate the complex dynamics that shape the Goldcloaks' portrayal in Martin's world.
Whether the Goldcloaks are simply ineffective or inherently corrupt, they serve as a compelling example of the dangers of unchecked power and the downfall of once-revered institutions. This intricacy makes them a rich and multi-dimensional aspect of the ASOIAF narrative.