Why the Debate Continues: Old vs. New NCERTs for UPSC Preparation

The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) exam is one of the most challenging and competitive examinations in India. As part of the preparation, candidates often debate the suitability of the old and new NCERT (National Council of Educational Research and Training) textbooks. This article explores the key points of this ongoing discussion and provides insights for aspirants to make informed decisions.

Content Changes

Old NCERTs:

Comprehensive and detailed particularly in subjects like History and Geography. Provide a strong foundational understanding essential for the UPSC exam.

New NCERTs:

Aim to simplify content for better accessibility. Some argue that the new versions may lack depth and critical analysis necessary for the UPSC exam.

Exam Pattern and Trends

The UPSC exam has shifted towards more analytical and application-based questions.

Some aspirants believe that the new NCERTs may not adequately prepare them for this evolving exam pattern. Others argue that the simplified content of the new NCERTs is sufficient for understanding core concepts.

Subject Relevance

Different subjects have varying levels of reliance on NCERT books:

Sociology and Political Science: May align well with the new NCERTs. History: May still benefit from the old versions for a deeper understanding of events and contexts.

Preparation Strategy

Aspirants often choose which textbooks to prioritize in their study plans:

Read Both Versions: To get a well-rounded perspective. Focus Exclusively: On one version based on personal comfort level and understanding.

Peer Influence and Recommendations

Recommendations from successful candidates and mentors can heavily influence decision-making:

If many successful candidates advocate for one version over the other, it can sway new aspirants.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice between old and new NCERTs depends on individual learning styles and specific subject needs. Many aspirants find value in using both versions to create a more comprehensive study approach for the UPSC exam.