Why Do Professional Librarians Remain Undervalued in North American Culture?
Even as I noted the lack of respect given to librarians in North American society, my former profession continues to be underestimated. This article explores the reasons behind this phenomenon, especially in the shadow of technological advancements, particularly AI and the prevalence of search engines like Google.
The Declining Status of Librarians in Modern Society
It is surprising that professional librarians have not garnered the high status they deserve. In today’s digital age, they risk becoming obsolete, or at the very least, significantly eroded by technological disruptions. The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) exacerbates this issue, as many routine tasks previously performed by librarians can be automated. Similarly, the vastness of information available through simple online searches has diminished the perceived necessity for traditional libraries, let alone their professional personnel.
Librarians: More Than Just Bookshelf Management
Upon my years as a college librarian, I discovered the true value of our role. Students relied on us for guidance and support in their academic pursuits. Contrary to popular perception, librarians are more than just bookshelf managers; they are expert information gatekeepers and educators. Their contributions to student success cannot be overstated.
It is also common for people to view librarians as 'nerds' until they need help with a research paper or project. This highlights the misconception that librarians are not appreciated until their expertise is necessary, a phenomenon known as 'unseen value'.
The Role of Right Circles in Valuing Librarians
One's perception of librarians is deeply influenced by the company one keeps. In literary and artistic circles, such as those involving poets, editors, and book publishers, librarians are held in high esteem. They are critical to the literary and cultural landscape, often playing a pivotal role in the promotion and circulation of literature.
For instance, the POLY: New Speculative Writing book series achieved significant recognition due to widespread library orders. My continued participation in the American Library Association (ALA) meetings and the positive impact of library acquisitions have further solidified the high status of librarians within these circles. Libraries serve as crucial venues for literary and cultural events, and many renowned writers have worked as librarians, especially in genres such as surrealism, imaginative literature, science fiction, and poetry.
Libraries as Incubators of Popular Culture
The continued existence of certain genres, such as science fiction, can be attributed to the efforts of librarians. During the Great Depression, libraries kept the genre alive, providing a fertile ground for emerging talent. The remarkable story of Ray Bradbury, who wrote Fahrenheit 451 while working in a library, exemplifies the impact of librarians.
Libraries are not just repositories of physical books; they are vibrant centers for cultural and intellectual exchange. They serve as performance spaces and venues for literary readings, fostering a dynamic and engaged literary community. Moreover, libraries play a crucial role in promoting small press publications, which often find their way into the hands of eager readers due to library recommendations.
High Status in Literary and Literary Circles
Librarians’ high status can be attributed to their active involvement in the literary and cultural spheres. They are integral to the success of various literary and creative endeavors. Without professional librarians, it is safe to say that a significant portion of popular culture would not exist as we know it today.
Libraries and their professional staff are often celebrated in literary and cultural events. The New York Public Library, one of the world's greatest repositories of knowledge, reached out to me for advice, highlighting the high esteem in which librarians are held.
The Importance of Circles in Perceiving Value
Status is often a function of the circles one moves in. Being part of literary and cultural circles provides a platform for librarians to demonstrate their value. Their contributions are recognized and appreciated, leading to a higher status within these circles.
In conclusion, the undervaluation of professional librarians in North American culture is a complex issue influenced by societal perceptions, technological advancements, and the unique role of libraries in cultural and intellectual growth. While the literary and cultural spheres recognize the indispensable role of librarians, the broader society still needs to acknowledge and appreciate their considerable contributions.