Why Are Catholic Schools So Strict?

The perceived strictness of Catholic schools might come as a surprise to those who have only encountered the more relaxed, perhaps modern, educational environments that have evolved in recent decades. The strictness in Catholic schools is rooted in a strong philosophical and doctrinal commitment to education and the upbringing of morally upright individuals. This article delves into the reasons behind the strict discipline in Catholic schools and why this approach is seen as beneficial.

The Foundation of Strict Discipline

Catholic schools expect their students to come prepared to learn, not to socialize. Discipline was always an essential component of the education provided by Catholic institutions. It was never simply seen as 'strict,' but rather a necessary framework to instill values and character in the young minds entrusted to their care. The schools aim to foster an environment conducive to learning, where disruptions are not tolerated.

The Contrast with Today's Youth

Today's youth, often characterized as being 'lazy,' 'rebellious,' and expecting an effortless 'good life,' present a stark contrast to the previous generation. While this characterization may vary in its accuracy, it serves to highlight a shift in societal values and expectations. The schools prepare students for the rigors of life, which require discipline and hard work, rather than soft-pedaling challenges to protect their sensibilities.

Personal Reflections from an Alumnus

I attended Catholic primary schools from 1958 to 1965 and a Catholic grammar school near Manchester, England, from 1965 to 1972. During these years, our schools were strict but not cruel. The intent was to provide us with a comprehensive education that opened doors to numerous opportunities. In contrast, I worked at a school where discipline was poor, classes were disorderly, and the head was absent more often than present, leading to very poor exam results. This environment made it exceedingly difficult for motivated students to succeed and realize their educational potential. Local public exam results in the area where I worked now rank 94th out of 94 education areas in England and Wales, a significant decline from their previous ranking of 93rd.

The Values Upheld by Catholic Schools

Respect, discipline, family values, and faith – all things that are not always prioritized in a secular world – are seen as strict by some. These values form the bedrock upon which the discipline in Catholic schools is built. The structured environment in these institutions is designed to instill a sense of responsibility and moral integrity in students. Such an environment is crucial in a world that often lacks guidance and structure.

The Role of Catholic Schools in Nurturing Good Citizens

Catholic schools do more than just teach basic educational skills; they teach students how to be good people and responsible citizens. This is achieved through a behavioral standard that is socially responsible and in line with Christian teachings and morals. The discipline of the body, fostered through strict rules and expectations, is believed to translate into the discipline of the mind. Students who lack discipline often display a lack of moral compass, as evidenced by the chaos in public schools.

Why Are Public Schools Less Disciplined?

It seems that the question should be inverted: why are public schools, which began centuries after Catholic schools, so unstructured? While public schools have their merits, the absence of a consistent behavioral framework can lead to a lack of discipline. Public schools often focus more on educational basics without the added emphasis on character and moral development. This focus on academic rigor alone can result in a moral vacuum that undermines long-term success and well-being.

Conclusion

Catholic schools are often stricter because they are deeply rooted in a tradition that values discipline, moral character, and academic excellence. While public schools have their unique strengths, the structured environment of Catholic schools provides a fertile ground for students to develop the qualities needed to navigate the complexities of modern life. The strictness in Catholic schools is not a flaw but a strength that prepares students for a lifetime of achievement and success.