The Great Thrash Metal Controversy: Who Should Replace Anthax?
Thrash metal fans often debate about the status and future of the genre's iconic bands. Recently, the discussion has centered around whether a member of the Big 4 of thrash metal should be replaced. Specifically, Anthrax has been under scrutiny, sparking debates about which band would best fill the void if Anthrax were to exit the scene.
Fair Competition: A Clash of Giants
With Testament often considered the fifth band alongside the Big 4 (Metallica, Slayer, Anthrax, and Megadeth), the decision to potentially replace Anthax is simplified to two formidable options: Exodus or Testament. Both bands hail from the San Francisco Bay Area (Bay Area thrash), each boasting a rich and distinctive history.
Exodus: The Bay Area Pioneers
Exodus has a strong claim as a frontrunner. Historically, they were formed in the heart of thrash metal's birthplace, contributing significantly to the genre's evolution. Their enduring popularity and consistent output make them a fitting replacement. Notably, Gary Holt, the founding guitarist of Exodus, is currently with Slayer, which brings up the question of who would take his place.
Testament: The Veteran Voice
Testament has also been in the spotlight. Inducted into the Metal Hall of Fame in 2022, they have a substantial legacy with a robust catalogue of memorable songs. While Testament was more popular than Anthax in the early days of thrash, their current lineup and recent activities suggest they could be a strong contender. The guitarist, Gary Holt, is a renowned talent but is currently with Slayer.
Speculation and Rumors
Rumors have abounded about the potential reunion of guitar virtuoso Kerry King with Paul Bostaph, Gary Holt, and Phil Anselmo, the frontman of Pantera. This potential lineup would consist of three of the most celebrated guitarists in thrash history, but the addition of a new bassist is a crucial piece of the puzzle. Rex (from Mwedeth and Metallica) might be a viable option, though his enthusiasm for touring is uncertain.
Exodus's Resurgence
Adding to the speculation, Anthax's John Bush is now back with the band, replacing the iconic Joey Belladonna. This move has revived interest in the band and their output, making Exodus's vulnerability more pronounced. Anthax has been working on new material for their upcoming album, leading fans to wonder about their future contributions.
The Future of Thrash
The debate over whether Anthax should be replaced underscores the evolving landscape of thrash metal. With the potential reunion of Kerry King with an Exodus without Holt, and continuing debates about Seth MacFarlane's influence on Megadeth, the future of thrash remains both exciting and uncertain. The choice of which Bay Area act to step into Anthax's shoes will ultimately be decided by the fans' desire for anthemic thrashing and the bands' ability to maintain the genre's legacy.
Conclusion
As thrash metal continues to evolve, the conversation around which band should step up when Anthax steps down remains open. Whether it is Exodus or Testament, or perhaps another band, the future of thrash is ripe with possibilities. Stay tuned for updates and continue the discussion on which band will wear the crown of big 4 in the upcoming era of thrash metal.
Note: This article is based on the current public discussion and speculations.