The Ethical Impartiality of Librarians

Librarians are often labeled as staunch adherents of the liberal ideology, which can be a source of tension in today's polarized society. However, it is important to recognize the professional ethical standards that guide their work and the rationale behind their commitment to the public's right to intellectual freedom.

Assumptions about Librarian Loyalty

There is a widespread assumption that librarians are predominantly liberal, with some individuals being intolerant of conservative ideas. This impression often stems from the belief that librarians support a wide range of narratives to cater to the diverse communities they serve. While it is true that there is a tendency within the profession to value diverse perspectives, it is vital to acknowledge that this does not equate to being solely liberal in ideology.

The Professional Side of Librarianship

Professionally, librarians adhere to ethical standards that prioritize the public's right to intellectual freedom. This means ensuring that all information is accessible and that the library's resources reflect a balance of viewpoints. For instance, if the public desires information on conservative African American ideas or on those who have detransitioned, such information should be made available, provided it does not infringe on the liberties of others. The budget constraints and ethical considerations are key factors in deciding what materials are included in the library's collection.

Perspectives from the Conservative Side

I have worked in a Republican think tank and found that various non-liberal materials were available there. Archivists and librarians in such settings are often professional and ethical, providing a diverse range of resources for researchers. This work requires a separation of personal beliefs from the public service mission. Like healthcare workers, archivists and librarians can set aside their personal differences and focus on providing impartial information.

The Role of Intellectual Freedom

Intellectual freedom is a core principle in librarianship. It is not just about providing access to a wide range of ideas but also about ensuring that the library serves the public's needs. Information workers must work to make information freely available, reflecting the founding ideals of the United States—life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. The separation of church and state is crucial for maintaining this objectivity and ensuring that the information provided is unbiased.

The Ethical Perspective on Diversity of Thought

If the political tide were to shift significantly towards another ideological perspective, such as Islam, librarians would face the same ethical challenge as they would under a democratic system. Conserving intellectual freedom and providing balanced information is essential, regardless of the prevailing beliefs. The role of an information worker is to ensure that all voices are heard, not to suppress or censor any particular viewpoint.

The Core of Human Experience

At its core, the work of librarians and archivists is about serving people and enriching their minds and hearts. The separation of church and state provides a framework for maintaining professional integrity and ethical standards. It allows us to remain impartial and serve all members of society, regardless of their beliefs. The ultimate goal is to foster understanding and respect among people with different viewpoints.

As we navigate the complex landscape of societal divide, it is necessary to recognize the professionalism and ethical dedication of librarians and archivists. Their aim is not to promote one ideology over another but to provide balanced and accessible information that serves the public's needs. This is a crucial aspect of their role in ensuring the preservation and dissemination of knowledge across diverse communities.