How to Punctuate a Sentence that Starts as a Question But Ends as a Statement

When writing a sentence that begins as a question and ends as a statement, it's important to know the correct punctuation. For instance, consider the following example: “Who is that guy I wish they would tell us”.

Correct Punctuation

The correct punctuation in this example would involve using a question mark for the first part and a period for the second part. A semicolon is not appropriate as the second part is not an independent clause closely related to the first. Here’s how to do it:

“Who is that guy?”

“I wish they would tell us.”

Who is that guy I wish they would tell us.”

Alternative Structure

If you want to keep both ideas in one sentence, you can use a coordinating conjunction:

“Who is that guy and I wish they would tell us.”

This format maintains the flow while clearly distinguishing the question from the statement.

Two Separate Sentences

Your example shows that the most important element might be the identity of the individual.

Alternatively, you could separate the sentences:

“Who is that guy?”

“I wish they would tell us.”

Writing them as two separate sentences ensures clarity and avoids confusion.

Revising the Question

You might also consider revising the question to improve its clarity and flow. For example:

“I wish they would tell us who the guy is.”

“I wish they’d identify the guy for us.”

Using Semicolons for Mixed Sentence Structures

A semicolon can be used to connect two closely related independent clauses, but it does not replace a question mark or an exclamation point. Here are some examples:

“I’m having some pie; would you like some?”

“Would you like some pie? I’m having some.”

In the first example, a semicolon connects two closely related independent clauses. In the second example, the question mark remains, as the statement follows the action.

Conclusion

When you need to write a sentence that starts as a question and ends as a statement, the best approach is often to use a question mark and a period separately. Alternatively, you can use a coordinating conjunction or separate the ideas into two sentences. For complex structures, consider revising the question to improve clarity and flow.