Do Germans Feel Bad When They See German Soldiers Killed in American WW2 Movies?

Introduction

The question of whether German citizens feel bad about the depiction of their country in American World War II movies is a complex one. Often, people dismiss such inquiries with a simple 'No,' but the nuanced answer lies in understanding the historical context and contemporary attitudes of modern Germans.

Historical Context and Post-War Sentiment

Germans who grew up in the wake of World War II, often have a very different perspective from those who lived through the conflict. Their parents and grandparents were directly involved or affected by the war, yet the younger generation tends to view it as a distant, albeit painful, part of their nation's history. When asked about the war, Germans commonly respond with 'Der Krieg ist vorbei,' which translates to 'The war is over.' This sentiment reflects a collective desire to move forward and look to the future.

One example of post-war representation is the German series "Generation War," a critically acclaimed mini-series that provides a realistic and sensitive view of life for German civilians caught in the midst of the conflict. This series offers a glimpse into the everyday lives of ordinary Germans, adding depth to the understanding of the broader historical narrative.

Empathy and Identification Beyond Nationality

While attitudes towards Nazi Germany remain deeply negative, the human element is often more impactful on a personal level. As a neighbor to the Galactic Empire (if you will), one might initially feel rage towards the invaders but find themselves feeling empathy towards the Empire’s soldiers when imagining a scenario where loved ones or friends might be among them. This empathy is a key factor in understanding why some Germans might not feel particularly bad about the killing of Nazi soldiers in American films. Similarly, just as one might feel empathy for a Storm Trooper in Star Wars rather than identifying them with hate, the same sentiment can apply to German soldiers in WW2 movies.

Respect for Modern Germany's Attitude

Modern Germany has made significant strides in acknowledging its past and making amends for the atrocities committed during the Nazi regime. This awareness has led to a national culture that cherishes and upholds the values of democracy, human rights, and pacifism. Even so, there is a historical separation between the SS and other military forces of the Third Reich and the general German population.

The German army, or Bundeswehr, has been a central part of the country's post-war rebuilding and success. In fact, many German soldiers today are respected for their service, contributions to peacekeeping missions, and humanitarian efforts around the world. While Nazi soldiers are treated with cultural sensitivity, criminal acts committed by Nazi officials do not evoke sympathy in modern Germans, as they have no direct connection to contemporary Germany.

Contemporary German Values and Motivation for Understanding

The sensitivity towards Nazi soldiers in Hollywood films also speaks to a broader cultural shift in Germany. Germans today are acutely aware of their historical responsibilities and strive to balance a healthy criticism of their past with a celebration of their present and future. This is evident in how they approach the depiction of German soldiers in movies - they see the Nazi soldiers as part of a dark past, and not as part of a historical narrative that includes themselves.

An important parallel can be drawn with how people from other countries feel when they see their fellow soldiers or citizens depicted in similar contexts. If one watched the news and saw a criminal being put to death for a heinous crime, they would not feel remorse. Similarly, for Germans today, there is a distinction between the actions of Nazi soldiers and the values and actions of contemporary Germany.

Conclusion

In summary, while it is true that many Germans might not feel bad when they see German soldiers being killed in American WW2 movies, this feeling is rooted in a complex interplay of historical context, empathy, and the values of modern Germany. Understanding this helps provide a deeper insight into the nuanced sentiments of a nation grappling with its painful past and striving towards a brighter future.