Choosing Between a PhD in Philosophy or Law School: A Comprehensive Guide

The decision to pursue a PhD in philosophy or attend law school can be quite daunting. Both paths offer unique advantages and can shape your future career trajectory in distinctly different ways. In this article, we will explore the benefits and drawbacks of each option, providing you with insights that may help inform your decision.

The Dilemma: Philosophy vs. Law School

For those who are weighing the options of a PhD in philosophy or a law degree, the choice can often feel like an either/or proposition. However, as we will see, this may not be the most practical approach to take. The type of doctorate you earn should not drastically alter your career aspirations, as both fields offer varied career paths, albeit with different demands and opportunities.

Intersection of Interests: My Experience

One individual who has navigated this decision point is my son, who pursued both a PhD in Linguistics and a law degree, both from the University of Chicago. Additionally, his undergraduate studies were completed at Dartmouth, and he holds a Master's degree in Logic from Carnegie Mellon. He initially harbored the intention of becoming a professor but later realized the potential benefits of a career in law due to its higher income potential. He now has a successful job with a big law firm in Manhattan, yet he acknowledges that teaching is still a passion for him.

Should You Compare the Two Programs?

When faced with the decision between these two programs, it is crucial to consider your ultimate goals. Have you applied to both schools or departments simultaneously? If not, applying to a PhD in philosophy or law school may not be an either/or proposition. Instead, it is important to recognize that both programs can offer different employment prospects and career trajectories. However, a PhD in the law field certainly has its merits, including the high demand for legal professionals in the labor market.

A Personal Perspective: PhD in Philosophy

I, too, once faced the decision between a PhD in philosophy and law school. Despite my affinity for philosophical thought, I ultimately chose law school, which turned out to be the worst decision in my life. Regretting it daily, I realized that the academic pursuit of philosophy did not align with my practical career goals. If you find yourself designing an academic path, philosophy can be an enriching experience, but it may not offer as many career opportunities outside of academia as law. It is essential to reflect on your long-term goals and consider your personal motivations for pursuing either a PhD in philosophy or a law degree.

Conclusion: Tailoring Your Path

The choice between a PhD in philosophy or law school ultimately depends on your personality, career aspirations, and personal preferences. While a PhD in philosophy can provide a deep understanding of complex ideas and theories, a law degree can offer a more practical and lucrative career path. Always consider the potential for a balanced life, as the type of doctorate you earn should not overly dictate your career decisions.
Regardless of your ultimate choice, remember that it is never too late to reassess and adjust your path. The key is to be open to different opportunities and to stay true to your evolving interests and goals.

Keywords: PhD in Philosophy, Law School, Career Prospects, Academic Path, Practical Career Goals, Alternative Opportunities